Concept2 RowErg vs WaterRower Oak with S4 Monitor
Disclosure: We earn a commission if you buy through our links, at no cost to you. It never affects our rankings.
Best for
Best overall
Best quiet rower
Measured specs Bars scale to the largest value shown. “Not listed” = not confirmed on the label or listing.
Key features
Features
- Air resistance, PM5 monitor
- 500 lb capacity
- Water resistance
- S4 monitor
Third-party seal
None listed
None listed
Our take
The gym and competition standard, no subscription needed.
Water resistance in a wood frame; quieter than air.
What it’s for
Rowing Machines: Air rowers are durable and standard in gyms; water rowers are quieter; connected rowers add classes but usually need a monthly membership. We compare resistance type, capacity, footprint, subscription cost and build.
Winner by category
| Max user / load capacity | WaterRower Oak with S4 Monitor |
|---|---|
| Footprint | WaterRower Oak with S4 Monitor |
| Warranty | Tie |
| Higher in our ranking | Concept2 RowErg (#1) |
“Winners” are only on confirmed numbers (higher is better, except sugar, footprint and price tier). They are not an overall verdict.